How much influence do you have over your manager, or even your manager’s manager?
One topic that keeps coming up in my coaching conversations is how to get an idea heard,
how to influence people higher up in the organisation. It comes up with clients from all
corners of the world, with middle and senior managers, but also with people who don’t hold
leadership positions at all. They simply have an idea they believe would benefit the
organisation.
By the time they bring this topic into coaching, they’ve usually tried a few things already,
without much success. How about you? Are you able to get your leaders on board with what
you’d like to achieve?
Let’s look at what tends to go wrong, and what might help!
Do We Have a Word for It?
The expression manage up is already widely used in English. Interestingly, though,
Hungarian for instance doesn’t really have a specific word for it yet (and I suspect the same is
true for quite a few other languages). We talk about advocating for our interests, lobbying,
influencing others.
As a linguist, I always find it fascinating when a language develops a word for a particular
phenomenon. But that’s probably more my interest than yours, so let’s get back to where
things can go wrong and what might help us navigate them.
The Pitfalls
Let me share what I notice in my clients, the things they do that make their own lives more
difficult. Ask someone else, and you’ll probably get a different list.
But here goes. (And while you’re reading, I invite you to do a little self-reflection: how often
do you slip up on these yourself?)
- You’re focused on convincing the other person that your idea is right.
Instead of taking the time to understand their perspective, what matters to them, and what their priorities are. - You keep trying the same strategy over and over again.
There’s little point in pushing something that isn’t working. When your idea gets rejected, it’s often because the other person hasn’t really understood it. And if you keep explaining it in exactly the same way, chances are they still won’t. - You’re using your own frame of reference.
You explain why your idea is a good one from your own perspective. But your frame of reference, your priorities and your needs don’t necessarily match those of the other person. - Your relationship with power.
What goes on in your head when you think about someone who has power? (Ooh, I really don’t like the word power, but I can’t quite avoid it here if I want to describe this phenomenon.)
If your relationship with power involves fear, insecurity or intimidation, that can make things more difficult for you.
The person who holds the power is human too. They have their own headaches, needs, wishes and interests.
Some Practical Things to Try
There are a few small, practical things worth experimenting with. I’m not saying they’ll all work with everyone, but they’re certainly worth a try.
- Tactical Empathy (Chris Voss)
Chris Voss used to be an FBI hostage negotiator. If anyone knows a thing or two about influencing others, it’s probably him. Needless to say, I also have a bit of an issue with the word tactical. As a coach, empathy is such a fundamental part of how we work that I find it difficult to think of it as something we use as a tactic. The essence of this approach is to put into words what we’ve understood about the other person’s motivations and priorities.
We don’t have to agree with them to be understanding. And we offer our understanding tentatively, leaving room for the other person to correct us.
For example:
“It seems like meeting the deadline is really important to you.”
“It sounds like gaining market share is your top priority right now.” - How Does Our Idea Support Their Priorities?
How can we present our idea in a way that also supports the other person’s priorities? You don’t need to twist your idea into something it’s not. You just need to find the points of connection. What could your idea bring to the table that would also help them achieve their goals?
(There’s that well-known English acronym, WIIFM, What’s In It For Me? That’s exactly what this is about: showing the other person what they stand to gain from our idea.)
So, what do you think? Worth giving these a try? Go for it!
And if you find yourself stuck, find someone who can help you move forward. Someone who can offer an outside perspective, help you recognise your own thinking traps, or perhaps simply bring some (genuine) empathy to the conversation.
Tamara Szabó
ICF Master Certified Coach (MCC), Advanced Certified Team Coach (ACTC)
Founder of Co-Create Coach Courses